The Lost World of Neanderthals, Hobbits, and Other Hominins

by | Aug 17, 2011 | Human Origins & the Paleolithic

It seems fantasies like The Lord of the Rings have cornered the market on “multi-species worlds”: on worlds peopled by dwarves, elves, goblins, and other not-quite-humans. Yet history has a claim on the multi-species world too. Or rather prehistory does. For most of prehistory, we Homo sapiens shared the planet with several species of upright, tool-making, fire-burning people.


Neanderthal child (imagined)

“Hominin” refers to Homo sapiens and our closest relatives: to extinct creatures far closer to us than chimps and bonobos, our closest relatives today. It’s likely our Stone Age ancestors ran into fellow hominins on a regular basis, or at least once in a while.

  • Neanderthals: Homo neanderthalensis lived in Europe and the Middle East until twenty or thirty thousand years ago. They looked like us but had protruding jaws and brows, sloping foreheads, and almost no chins. They also had thick bodies, far stronger than ours. And they had larger heads and brains than we do, which may mean they were smarter, though that’s not clear. (Brain size isn’t the only factor governing intelligence.) Neanderthals evolved during the ice ages of the last few hundred thousand years, so they were adapted to cold climates, though they lived in some warm places too. They were mighty hunters and sophisticated tool-maker.
  • a Neanderthal ancestor?

    Homo erectus (reconstructed)

    Homo erectus: H.E.’s lived in Eurasia and Africa until around 40,000 years ago, occupying a wider range than the Neanderthals. They shared many physical features with their Neanderthal cousins, including thick, powerful bodies and protruding brows and jaws, though H.E. jaws were more ape-like. They were swift, deadly hunters, and they may have been the first creatures to harness fire. H.E.’s made unsophisticated stone tools, though, and they had much smaller brains than we do. So anthropologists think they had limited intelligence, possibly equivalent to small children. It’s not hard to imagine our ancestors finding H.E.’s terrifying—the ultimate savages—with their immense strength and speed, ape-like jaws, and child-like minds.

Homo floresiensis (reconstructed, at the Swedish Museum of Natural History)

  • Flores Hobbits: Homo floresiensis stood about three and a half feet tall. Nicknamed “hobbits,” these hominins had chimp-sized brains but apparently made sophisticated stone tools, so they may have had human-level intelligence. Anthropologists have found H. floresiensis fossils in only one place: the remote island of Flores in Indonesia. That makes sense because dwarf species often evolve on isolated islands, due to low food supplies and a lack of predators to fight and flee. Flores hobbits probably lasted until about 12,000 years ago. (A minority among the experts think Homo floresiensis is a figment of anthropological imagination. They argue that the Flores “hobbit” fossils come from diseased Homo sapiens.)
  • Denisova Hominin: We know almost nothing about the newly-discovered Denisova hominin because anthropologists have only found a single fossil: a juvenile’s finger bone from about 40,000 years ago. Researchers found the fossil in Siberia and identified the new species from DNA.

How did all these hominin species interact? It’s likely they killed each other pretty regularly, given the violent nature of the Homo genus. But some interactions must have been friendlier. There’s reason to believe Stone Age Homo sapiens adopted some of the Neanderthals’ stone tool kits, and visa-versa. More intriguing, anthropologists believe Homo sapiens and Neanderthals mated and that many of us have a few ounces of Neanderthal blood in our veins. Genetic evidence also suggests that Denisova hominins mated with both Neanderthals and humans, and that some of us have a little Denisova blood too.

Maybe we Homo sapiens just had the best smile.

Did the various hominins talk to each other? Some anthropologists think Homo sapiens has an all-time monopoly on speech. If so, our hominin cousins probably communicated with expressions, gestures, and a restricted vocabulary of sounds. But it’s also quite possible that some or all of our hominin cousins could talk. If so, perhaps the cousins got together once in a while to chat.

We don’t know what happened to the other hominins. Species disappear from the fossil record all the time, so their extinction isn’t necessarily surprising. But hominins have been around more than five million years, and through most of that time, multiple species was the norm, or at least common. So it is interesting that we suddenly have the planet all to ourselves. It’s likely our ancestors drove the other hominins to extinction, out-competing them and even systematically killing them.

If Homo sapiens did have a monopoly on language, our victory makes sense. The Neanderthals and Homo erectus may have been stronger, and the Neanderthals may even have been smarter, but there’s no substitute for language. It allows trade and sharing of ideas, and that leads to better technology and strategy. But what if our hominin cousins could speak? What then was our advantage?



© 2011, 2020 by David W. Tollen. All rights reserved.


  1. Dwarf Elder

    Neanderthals = Dwarves
    Homo Erectus= Orcs
    Heidelberg man = Trolls
    Denisovans= Elves
    Flores man = Hobbits
    Mammoth= Ice giants
    Even Tolkien’s Creation Myth is more believable than the established religions of the world.
    The “music of the Ainur” is string theory.
    Perhaps Tolkien was able to tap into genetic memory and see the ancient world in his minds eye.

  2. joselegarcia

    Homo sapiens are de freaking elves



  1. Homo ghostus | Pints of History - […] I reported in an earlier post that Homo sapiens once shared the world with at least four other hominins:…
  2. Did Hobbits Live among Us Recently? | Pints of History - […] species they named Homo floresiensis: a small relative of ours often called “hobbits.” (See my post on hobbits and…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *